Unit 1
Arguing from Evidence
Big question
How do you build an argument that holds up?
Overview
The year opens with the one skill everything else leans on, building an argument. Students learn the three parts of a strong argument: a claim, the evidence that backs it, and the reasoning that connects the two. They then practice what to do when good sources disagree, how to spot logical fallacies, and how to make a claim defensible. The unit closes with an argument brief of their own.
The Islamic lens is Bring your proof. The Qur'an answers a bare claim with a challenge, "Bring your proof, if you are truthful" (Al-Baqarah 2:111). Learning to back a claim with evidence and reasoning answers that call, and every argument is built with humility, because the final word on what is true belongs to Allah alone.
Chapters
- 01
Claim, Evidence, and Reasoning
The three blocks that hold up every strong argument.
- 02
When Sources Conflict
Why good sources disagree, and a framework for weighing them.
- 03
Logical Fallacies
What a fallacy is, five common ones, and how to check your own work.
- 04
Defensible Arguments
Finding the answer the evidence can actually support.
- 05
Argument Brief
The unit project, an argument of the student's own.
Components
- Workbook
- Teacher's Guide
- Activity Pages
Themes
- Islamic lens: Bring your proof
Standards
| Framework | Code | Description |
|---|---|---|
| C3 Framework | D3.1.3-5 | Gather relevant information from multiple sources while using the origin, structure, and context to guide the selection. |
| C3 Framework | D3.2.3-5 | Use distinctions among fact and opinion to determine the credibility of multiple sources. |
| C3 Framework | D3.4.3-5 | Use evidence to develop claims in response to compelling questions. |
| C3 Framework | D4.1.3-5 | Construct arguments using claims and evidence from multiple sources. |
| C3 Framework | D4.3.3-5 | Present a summary of arguments and explanations to others outside the classroom. |
| C3 Framework | D4.4.3-5 | Critique arguments. |
| Common Core | RI.4.1 | Refer to details and examples when explaining what a text says. Practiced in every Reading Check. |
| Common Core | RI.4.3 | Explain events and ideas in a historical text, including what happened and why. |
| Common Core | W.4.1 | Write opinion pieces that support a point of view with reasons. |
| Common Core | SL.4.1 | Engage in collaborative discussions, through partner games and challenges. |
Inside the unit
Four parts
- 01
The Student Workbook
The unit's chapters and short lessons, with the reading, activity boxes, and an Islamic lens.
- 02
The Teacher Guide
One for every unit, written against the workbook, so page references, activity box names, and answer keys match.
- 03
The Unit Project
Every unit ends in a project that pulls the chapters together, such as an argument brief, a museum exhibit, a portfolio, an atlas, or a panel.
- 04
Activity Pages
A printable pack of activity pages at the back of each workbook, for partner work and projects.
